原帖由 loooop 于 2007-12-7 21:24 发表
FSU上的讨论看看就是啦,当不得真
我是觉得他们有一部分讲的还是有道理的,而且我发现一个很有趣的现象,就是越是喜欢D/W的人,越是觉得他们全美最多只能拿第三,然后分析G/P退出大奖赛是G/P的优势,N/B和S/B也很厉害之类blablablabla~~~相反那些不怎么关注D/W的人,却讲大话说他们肯定拿第二什么的,interesting~~我现在是没法纠结C/J和K/N了,反正再纠结C/J也参加不了世锦赛,K/N也掀不翻Dom/Sha,于是转过来纠结Del//Sch和D/W的命运了,sigh~~
ps,Golden Skate上有人全文翻译了Zhulin最近的一篇长篇采访,主要是谈当下花滑局势的,在这里:http://forum.hdldemo.com/forum/showthread.php?t=18366
虽然主要提到的是俄罗斯选手,不过比较的部分很有意思,比如Dom/Sha和K/N的比较,M/T和K/S的比较,我把朱大叔谈两对冰舞的比较贴过来:
Q…. With Oksana Domnina and Maksim Shabalin winning in Moscow witha record score, does it mean that all talk about the possibility thatYana Khokhlova and Sergei Novitski gaining the number 1 status inRussia no has no foundation?–
“I cannot give a categorical answer because these pairs have not yetcompeted directly against each other. Moreover, Domnina and Shabalincompeted in Russia. I was in Paris, where Khokhlova-Novitski skated, soI can say that we have two excellent pairs. The strong aspects ofOksana and Maksim are, of course, beauty, wonderful lines, excellentstroking. The team is statuesque; they look great. But there arecertain difficulties connected with the new rules. Having traveled todifferent competitions, I can say that I have come to the conclusionthat the female dance partners are getting smaller. Thanks to the newrules, they get points from being small and easy to maneuver in tricks.The judges pay less attention to the composition of programs now, tohow people look on the ice, to the culture of dance. In general, it’salready a new kind of sport, one that I understand less and less.”
Q. Does it mean that Khokhlova’s acrobatic style is preferred to Domnina’s academic approach?
“I cannot say that. I was thrilled by the skating of Yana and Sergei inParis. Their free dance is spectacular. Ira Zhuk and Sasha Svninin haveworked for glory. I am sure that thanks to this dance they will makeeven more noise this season. Although, in my opinion, Oksana and Maksimwill remain the number 1 pair in the country. But I wouldn’t say it’sall clear skies and sunny days for them.”
|